Wednesday, December 28, 2005

Transcript of Patricia Santangelo and Cary Sherman December 27th Appearance on CNN's "American Morning" with Miles O'Brien

December 27, 2005

O'BRIEN: A multibillion-dollar recording industry still unloading both barrels on those who download music illegally. Normally the defendants in these cases -- and there are about 17,000 of them now -- are young people, high-schoolers or college age who rip songs with impunity. But what about a 43-year-old divorced mother of five who doesn't know Kazaa from a kazoo?

She also is ensnared in that legal net, and she is fighting back. Her name is Patricia Santangelo. She joins us here and now.

Patty, good to have you with us.


O'BRIEN: When you heard that you were going to be sued by the recording industry, as a parent my first inclination will be, well, how much is it going to cost me to just make this go away?

Was that was your first inclination?

Not really. My first was, we didn't do this.

O'BRIEN: You didn't do it.

SANTANGELO: I didn't do this.

O'BRIEN: All right. What happened with your computer, though?

SANTANGELO: What happened was that the IP address -- the Cablevision company contacted me first. They were subpoenaed by the record industry for my IP address. So actually, originally my IP address was...

O'BRIEN: This is the Internet protocol address...


O'BRIEN: ... which is like the computer's phone number, essentially.


O'BRIEN: And that's how they go out and find people who use this file-sharing freeware service. Kazaa is one of them.

All right. So go ahead. SANTANGELO: So the IP address was sued.

O'BRIEN: All right.

SANTANGELO: And I was contacted by the record industry. And to avoid being named in a lawsuit, I could have very well have settled financially.

O'BRIEN: Right. But you did not. Why not?

SANTANGELO: I was told at the time I had no music. There was no music on the computer that I owned.

I no longer lived at that same address that that IP address came from. So I told them that I couldn't sign a, you know, document stating that I was going to stop do something that was being done. And I just wasn't getting information about how it happened.

O'BRIEN: But were there songs that were downloaded perhaps by your kids, and that in some way is what led them to sue this IP address?

SANTANGELO: Yes, I'm sure that they, most likely, like I said, found a Kazaa file. The thing is, is that none of my children downloaded Kazaa onto my computer. They didn't download the file- sharing program.


SANTANGELO: Without the file-sharing program, I'm assuming that none of this would have happened.

O'BRIEN: All right. But the fact is there was some illegal music on this computer. You just didn't know about it.

SANTANGELO: I knew nothing about any illegal music.

O'BRIEN: So you don't know -- you don't -- you barely know how to check e-mail, much less know what an IP address is.


O'BRIEN: But I mean as far as knowing what Kazaa is all about...

SANTANGELO: No, I didn't understand the process of sharing files over the Internet or anything like that.

O'BRIEN: Why do you think it's important to fight this, though?

SANTANGELO: Everything I've learned since this started. I wasn't sure at first, but I've been reading a lot about the lawsuits, and a lot of people like me are being sued. And they really didn't know. And it seems like no one's protecting us from these lawsuits.

O'BRIEN: All right. But doesn't a parent have a responsibility to police this kind of thing? And certainly from the case of the recording industry, whoever owns the computer has some responsibility over it, right?

SANTANGELO: The person that owns the computer?

O'BRIEN: Yes. Yes.

SANTANGELO: Certainly. I think a lot of children have Internet access, and I did use parental controls on their AOL accounts, because that's all they use.

O'BRIEN: Right.

SANTANGELO: And I should have been notified if something was downloaded. Or, you know, I didn't even think it was possible for them to be able to do it. So I did -- I did try to set it up the best I knew how.

O'BRIEN: But, of course, you have limited technological knowledge on what to do.

SANTANGELO: I had -- exactly. And I also was working full time and had five children, who had a lot of friends.

O'BRIEN: All right. We can relate to it.

Sit tight here for just a moment. We're going to bring in the other side of this.

The recording industry joining us now is Cary Sherman from Washington. He is the president of RIAA, the Recording Industry Association of America.

Cary, you just heard Patty's story. And I know you don't want to go on -- come on with her, which tells me you're a little bit walking on egg shells on a public relations front here.

Are you concerned about the message that this sends, that this woman who doesn't know much about computers is suddenly thrown into this big court case?

CARY SHERMAN, PRESIDENT, RIAA: Well, the message that we're trying to send is that uploading or downloading music without authorization on the Internet is Illegal.

O'BRIEN: I know, but is that her fault? Is that her fault, though?

SHERMAN: Well, but somebody has to assume responsibility for what's happening with kids. And I think parents need to have some kind of conversation with their kids about how to use the computer the right way and the wrong way.

I'm sure that Ms. Santangelo would be very concerned if she found out that one of her kids had shoplifted a CD and would want to know about it and take action about it. And we have to send the same message to parents and kid across the country, because what they're doing collectively is decimating the music industry. O'BRIEN: All right. Well, there is a difference here, though. If I found out my kids had shoplifted, I would go to the store owner and have the child return the item, and so on and so forth. I doubt it would end up in a lawsuit which in her case has cost $24,000 in legal fees thus far.

Is there another way to approach this problem? Because, sad to say, it's not stopping it.

SHERMAN: Well, we certainly have approached this problem with settlements. We were disappointed that Ms. Santangelo didn't take advantage of an opportunity to get rid of this case quickly, as most people have when they find that somebody in their household or somebody using their computer was in the wrong.

And we tried to be very fair and reasonable about this and take these matters up on a case-by-case basis. But the important thing is to get the message out there that this is illegal.



O'BRIEN: It might get that message out that it's illegal, but there's also another message which comes out, which is a question of fairness. Is it fair to go after a divorced mother of five who doesn't have a lot of financial means, who really didn't know anything about this and thought she was doing all she could to protect her kids online?

SHERMAN: And we understand that point. And the reality is that an overwhelming number of people who have been sued tell us the same story, that they didn't know what was going on, they didn't know it was illegal, and so on and so forth.

O'BRIEN: And so what do you say? You just tell them -- say, tell it to the judge? Is that it?

SHERMAN: We basically try to settle at a reasonable number, taking into account all the circumstances of the particular case. In this case, if Ms. Santangelo did not do this, then she should tell us who did, and we would modify the complaint accordingly.

O'BRIEN: Oh, well that puts a parent in a tough position. You know that. Yes.

SHERMAN: Well, but parents have to assume...

O'BRIEN: Would you do that as a parent?

SHERMAN: Parents have to assume some responsibility for their kids. I would probably do what you said you would do, which would be settle the case and let that be a lesson for the kid. We had one grandfather who had those kids work off the amount that he paid to settle as a way of teaching them a lesson and making this a family event. O'BRIEN: All right. Cary Sherman, thanks very much.

Patty Santangelo, good luck.

However it turns out, we appreciate you both joining us, shedding some light on this situation.

Keywords: copyright download upload peer to peer p2p file sharing filesharing music movies indie label freeculture creative commons pop/rock artists riaaradar

1 comment:

Flickrdoodle said...

I discovered Ms. Santangelo's story posted on where it is getting quite a bit of attention.

I do not approve of illegal music downloads, but putting her through this financial trauma is far worse. Sherman comes across as a modern day Joseph McCarthy.

Is there a fund set up to assist Ms. Santangelo with the legal fees already accumulated? If I understand correctly, she is currently without legal representation. Is this true?